I don't have trouble with rules if they are fairly applied, in the bar, the bordello, or the boardroom. Dieselpig made a convincing charge that posters have a responsibility to self-regulate, and i concur, mostly. However, none of us would expect that just bec our employees had framed a few houses before that we could tell them to go out there and do that again and we'd check back in six weeks. If the eave edges didn't match up, should the crew be fired for insubordination or should the boss reconsider how realistic her expectations are?
It was clear from the time i came on board in 2000 that the forum wouldn't self-regulate. I'm a practical kinda gal, so i vote for what works.